top of page
CVC Engineers Pte Ltd

10 Reasons Building Submissions Get Rejected in Singapore and How to Avoid Them

Nov 12
5 min read

Building submissions in Singapore are usually held up, not rejected outright: the agency issues a Written Direction listing what to correct, and the application stays open until the Qualified Person (QP) resubmits. The ten reasons below each rest on a published rule or guidance, from incomplete documents and the wrong QP discipline to missing URA permission, a missing Accredited Checker certificate and missing landlord or MCST consent. This is a checklist of rule-based causes, not a count: no agency publishes rejection rates, and none are claimed here.

Written in November 2026 from published rules; check the linked official sources for updates.

The ten reasons, with the rule behind each

  1. Incomplete documents. The rule: BCA's service standard applies only once complete documents are submitted, and its structural plan page lists them: the application form, signed structural plans, building plans for reference, signed and endorsed calculations, a valid planning permission, lodgement receipt or no-objection letter from URA, the plan fee computation, and buildability score calculations where applicable. How to avoid it: check your package against BCA's list before submitting. Read: BP and ST submissions.

  2. The wrong QP discipline. The rule: a QP is a registered architect or a PE with a valid practising certificate, but only a QP who is a PE in the civil or structural discipline can apply for structural plan approval. How to avoid it: confirm the structural QP's branch and practising certificate. Read: how to check a Professional Engineer.

  3. Missing URA permission before BCA. The rule: BCA states that the QP must obtain written permission from URA before applying for building plan approval, and a provisional permission is not a written permission. How to avoid it: confirm the planning status first. Read: URA first, then agencies, then BCA.

  4. A missing Accredited Checker certificate. The rule: an AC certificate and evaluation report are needed unless the works are minor building works in the Fourth Schedule of the Building Control Regulations; additions and alterations that materially affect key structural elements need one, and excavation or earth retaining structures above 4 m need an AC. How to avoid it: decide early whether the works are minor. Read: Accredited Checker.

  5. Generic replies to written directions. The rule: BCA's CORENET X Good Practices Guidebook says to avoid generic replies such as "complied with" or "noted", because they often lead to additional queries, and records that some teams do not fully address comments even after two rounds. How to avoid it: answer each comment with what changed and where. Read: Written Directions.

  6. Outdated documents in resubmissions. The rule: the same guidebook and Code of Practice material advises against uploading outdated documents, models or plans in a resubmission. How to avoid it: version-control the package and remove superseded sheets.

  7. Unauthorised existing works. The rule: for landed houses, unauthorised parts of the existing house cannot be retained under lodgment, and building works without approved plans or a permit carry a fine of up to $200,000, imprisonment of up to 2 years, or both. How to avoid it: survey the existing building against approved plans before design. Read: regularisation of unauthorised works and unauthorised works enforcement.

  8. Missing site investigation contents. The rule: Regulation 31 of the Building Control Regulations requires the design QP to carry out proper and adequate site investigation; BCA requires fieldwork by an inspection body accredited by the Singapore Accreditation Council, laboratory reports from SAC-accredited laboratories (circular APPBCA-2025-16, 1 September 2025), and a site investigation report endorsed by a PE. How to avoid it: plan the investigation before design. Read: soil investigation.

  9. The wrong submission route. The rule: the route depends on the works and size. Insignificant building works need no BCA approval; ERSS up to 1.5 m needs none, 1.5 m to 4 m needs a QP only, above 4 m an AC; CORENET X is mandatory for new projects of 5,000 sqm GFA and above from 1 October 2026, while smaller projects may stay on CORENET 2.0. How to avoid it: confirm the route before preparing drawings. Read: insignificant building works, ERSS thresholds and the CORENET X guide.

  10. Missing landlord or MCST consent. The rule: where land is leased, landowner consent such as JTC's plan consent is part of the sequence; in strata developments the MCST may require its approval and a PE's endorsement under its by-laws, and works affecting appearance or structural integrity need its authorisation (section 37(4) of the BMSMA, BCA Strata Management Guide 14). How to avoid it: obtain written consent before submitting. Read: JTC factory renovation consent and condo renovation MCST requirements.

What is the difference between a Written Direction and a rejection?

A Written Direction keeps the application open and tells the QP what to correct, whereas a Notice of Disapproval is a separate outcome at the end of processing. Each Written Direction adds at least one more review cycle, so the published clocks apply again; with an Accredited Checker, BCA's standard for subsequent submissions is 14 working days. BCA also states that it needs longer where a QP's previous submissions showed poor quality, such as a high number of Written Directions.

What has not changed

  • Works cannot start on a Written Direction reply; they need approved plans and, for structural works, the permit.

  • Each agency still decides under its own law, and the QP remains responsible. See the handbook hub and timeline planner.

Common mistakes in avoiding rejection

  • Treating the checklist above as a guarantee. Agencies assess each submission on its merits.

  • Fixing the drawings but not the response letter.

  • Resubmitting one agency's comments and overlooking another's on a joint submission.

  • Starting works while a Written Direction is outstanding.

FAQ

Why was my BCA submission rejected?

Most often it is a Written Direction rather than a rejection. Read each comment, which usually points to missing documents, a non-compliance or a clarification.

Can I submit to BCA with a provisional permission from URA?

BCA states that the QP must obtain written permission from URA before applying for building plan approval.

Do all structural submissions need an Accredited Checker?

No. Minor building works listed in the Fourth Schedule do not, but most additions that materially affect key structural elements do.

How do I avoid a second round of comments?

Submit a complete package and answer each comment specifically, stating what changed and on which sheet.

Do you have rejection statistics?

No. No agency publishes rejection rates, so this guide does not give any.

Sources

CVC Engineers is a multidisciplinary practice that takes architectural, civil, structural and geotechnical scope under one appointment, including BCA submissions and PE endorsement services. WhatsApp +65 9342 7551. Last reviewed: November 2026.

Recent Posts

See All
Singapore Building Compliance Handbook 2027

A map of Singapore building compliance rules for 2027: PE endorsement, QP submissions, geotechnical, demolition, inspection, factories, landed houses, procurement and a dated 2027 at-a-glance list, wi

 
 
 

Comments


© 2024 CVC Engineers. All rights reserved.

bottom of page