Soil Nails Ground Anchors and Struts in Singapore: How Excavations Are Supported
Excavations and cut slopes in Singapore are held up by one of four support systems: steel struts and walers, concrete ring struts, ground anchors or soil nails. The rules that govern them come from the Building and Construction Authority (BCA): Advisory Note 1/09 requires every support system to survive the loss of one strut, and the Framework on Risk-Based Slope Design (APPBCA-2024-01) requires temporary anchors to be removable, a consent letter for anchors or nails that cross the boundary, and monitoring of at least 5% of anchors. This article explains how each system works and what BCA requires. It is part of our geotechnical engineering guide.
What are the main ways to support an excavation?
A retaining wall on its own can only cantilever for a shallow depth, so deeper excavations add supports that either prop the wall from inside or tie it back into the ground outside.
Steel struts and walers: horizontal props spanning between opposite walls. The usual choice for basements and cut-and-cover works.
Concrete ring struts: a reinforced concrete ring that carries the earth pressure in hoop compression and leaves the centre of the excavation open.
Ground anchors: tendons grouted into the ground behind the wall and stressed against it. They keep the excavation free of props.
Soil nails: closely spaced bars grouted into a slope or cut face to reinforce the soil mass itself.
Permanent floor slabs can also act as the props in top-down construction: see top-down and bottom-up basements. The wall types these supports act on are covered in ERSS wall types.
How do steel struts and walers work?
A waler is a horizontal beam fixed along the wall that collects the earth and water pressure, and the struts are compression members that carry that load across the excavation to the opposite wall. Long struts are held against buckling by king posts and bracing. Because the whole system is in compression, any gap or soft spot in the load path lets the wall move before the strut takes load.
BCA's design considerations form (Annex A to Advisory Note 1/09), which the Qualified Person (QP) signs with the calculations, lists the details that must be allowed for:
Structural adequacy of the wall and supporting system, including walers, struts and anchors.
Proper continuous concrete packing between waler and wall, preloading of struts, adequate stiffeners and temperature effect.
Restraints in connections, ties and bracings.
Surcharge loads of at least 10 kPa, including construction loads and loads from adjacent structures.
Varying load conditions during the stages of construction, including removal stages.
Advisory Note 1/09 also states that temporary earth retaining or stabilising structures (ERSS) shall not have a lower factor of safety than permanent works and that no material overstress is allowed. Where re-used steel is used, the design must fully consider imperfections and the condition of the material. BCA's ERSS submission requirements (August 2026) note that a quality assurance scheme for reused struts has been incorporated into BC1:2023.
When are concrete ring struts used?
Concrete ring struts are used for circular or near-circular excavations, such as shafts and large basements, where an unobstructed working space is worth the cost of casting the ring. Earth pressure pushing inward from all sides is resisted as compression around the ring, in the way an arch carries load. The ring is cast against the wall at each level as excavation proceeds. Its weakness is sensitivity to unbalanced loading: if one side is excavated ahead of the other, or the ground differs across the site, the ring bends instead of working in pure compression, so the excavation sequence is part of the design. Shafts for utility works have their own BCA guideline: see tunnelling, pipe jacking and shafts.
What does BCA require for ground anchors?
BCA's Framework on Risk-Based Slope Design (APPBCA-2024-01, 2 January 2024), Appendix G, sets the requirements for ground anchors supporting slopes and retaining walls.
Definition: a temporary ground anchor has a design life of 2 years or less, following BS EN 1537.
Robustness: the design shall consider one anchor failure as an accidental load case.
Boundary: anchors inserted beyond the land boundary encroach on and obstruct future development of the adjacent land. A consent letter from the adjacent landowner shall be obtained before the design proposal is developed and submitted.
Removal: for temporary anchors, removable type anchors shall be adopted and all temporary anchors shall be removed. This is to be clearly specified on the approved plans.
Monitoring: a minimum of 5% of the anchors should be monitored regularly during their design life, whether temporary or permanent, in accordance with BS EN 1537. Working space for re-stressing and replacement must be provided.
Permanent anchors without long-term monitoring are to be designed for failure of a whole row of anchors.
Design approach: Approach 1 based on BS 8081 or Approach 2 based on SS EN 1997-1, with testing to SS EN 1997, BS EN 1537 and BS EN ISO 22477-5.
For removable anchors in staged excavations, the framework advises a lock-off load of 110% of the design preload, and notes that the looped strand in U-turn type anchors loses strength at the bend, so a reduction factor derived by test should be applied. Advisory Note 1/09 adds that site investigation points for anchored walls should be sited along the line of the probable fixed anchor zone.
What does BCA require for soil nails?
Soil nail design in Singapore refers to BS 8006-2, because SS EN 1997-1 does not cover soil nail design; where the two conflict, the partial factors in BS 8006-2 govern. This is stated in paragraph 5.9 of APPBCA-2024-01, and Appendix F adds the specific rules.
Suitability: soil nailing is applicable for ground with undrained shear strength of 50 kPa or greater.
Robustness: the design shall consider one nail failure as an accidental load case.
Definition: a temporary soil nail has a design life of less than 2 years.
Boundary: nails beyond the land boundary need a consent letter from the adjacent landowner, and for temporary nails fibre reinforced plastic should be considered instead of steel to avoid encumbering the neighbouring land.
Execution follows BS EN 14490, and permanent soil nailed slopes need long-term monitoring, inspection and maintenance.
A soil nail differs from an anchor in that it is not stressed: it picks up load only as the soil deforms, so nails are installed top-down in short lifts with a facing applied to each lift. Slope design generally is covered in slope stability in Singapore and retaining walls and slopes for landed houses.
What is the one-strut failure check?
The one-strut failure check is a robustness requirement in paragraph 14 of BCA Advisory Note 1/09 (2 April 2009): the ERSS must be robust and have enough redundancy to avoid catastrophic collapse from an isolated case of overloading or failure of any one element. In practice the designer removes a strut in the analysis and shows that the wall, walers and adjacent struts can redistribute the load. The same paragraph requires the design to consider:
Accidental load.
Material deficiencies and construction imperfections.
Abnormal loads, particularly construction surcharges and higher groundwater levels from flooding or water-filled tension cracks.
Eccentric loads and out-of-balance forces from the support system, for example from inclined anchors or struts.
Other Advisory Note 1/09 requirements that shape the support design are the allowable wall deflection of 0.5% of excavation depth where structures lie within one excavation depth, sensitivity analyses instead of a single one-off analysis, and the rule that jet grout or deep soil mixing shall not be used as part of the structural support or compressive strutting system. See deep excavation requirements.
Why are struts preloaded, and how are they removed?
Struts are preloaded by hydraulic jacks so that they take load immediately and the wall does not have to move to compress the strut and close gaps in its connections. Preloading is one of the items the QP confirms on Annex A. Advisory Note 1/09 warns that caution shall be exercised when evaluating strut force by hydraulic jacking: besides calibrated jacks, the loads shall be independently confirmed by a calibrated load cell.
Removal is a design stage in its own right. As the permanent structure is built upward from the base slab, each strut level is removed only after the slab or wall below it can take over the load, and each removal stage must be analysed. BCA's site inspection and approval record (Annex C) requires the builder to obtain the QP's approval before proceeding with excavation or strut or anchor works at each level, and the Accredited Checker's review covers the removal of struts or anchors at the next stage.
How are support systems monitored?
As a minimum, Advisory Note 1/09 requires monitoring of wall and ground deformation, anchor or strut loads and piezometric pressures, inside and outside the excavation. Strut and anchor loads are measured with two instrument types.
Load cells: placed in the load path at the strut end or anchor head to read force directly.
Strain gauges: fixed to the strut section to infer force from strain. Advisory Note 1/09 requires them to be properly installed, calibrated and checked, because readings are affected by non-uniform stresses, temperature, joints, strut installation and preloading.
Readings are compared with predetermined values for each construction stage and strut level. The alert level is 70% of the allowable wall deflection and the work suspension level is the allowable limit itself, at which work must stop. The QP reports results to BCA monthly, and immediately if the alert or work suspension level is exceeded. More in instrumentation and monitoring and the observational method.
Which authority and documents govern excavation support?
BCA governs under the Building Control Act 1989, and four documents carry the detail.
Advisory Note 1/09 on ERSS, 2 April 2009: design, robustness, control strategies and monitoring.
ERSS submission requirements, August 2026: who must be appointed. Plan approval starts above 1.5 m, an Accredited Checker above 4 m, and a PE(Geo) and AC(Geo) above 6 m for geotechnical building works.
Geotechnical building works submission requirements, June 2026: the support system and any ground improvement layer are submitted as part of the system.
Framework on Risk-Based Slope Design, APPBCA-2024-01: soil nails and ground anchors.
What goes wrong with excavation support?
Support failures usually start at a connection or a sequence error, not in the middle of a member. The recurring causes are excavating below the next strut level before that strut is installed and preloaded, waler connections without stiffeners or packing, struts removed before the permanent slab has gained strength, anchors installed across a boundary without consent and then left in the ground, and strain gauge readings accepted without temperature correction or a load cell check.
FAQ
Do ground anchors need my neighbour's consent?
Yes, if they extend beyond your land boundary. BCA's framework requires a consent letter from the adjacent landowner before the design is developed and submitted.
Can temporary ground anchors be left in the ground?
No. The framework requires removable anchors for temporary use and requires all temporary anchors to be removed.
How many ground anchors must be monitored?
A minimum of 5% of the anchors, regularly during their design life.
Which code is used for soil nail design in Singapore?
BS 8006-2, with execution to BS EN 14490, as referenced in APPBCA-2024-01.
What is the difference between a soil nail and a ground anchor?
A ground anchor is stressed against the wall and carries load from the day it is locked off. A soil nail is passive and takes load only as the ground moves.
Is a strutted excavation always geotechnical building works?
No. It becomes geotechnical building works when the excavation or ERSS is more than 6 m deep and is not within the exempt cases. Between 4 m and 6 m a QP and an Accredited Checker are required.
Sources
CVC Engineers advocates education and public awareness, and has a dedicated team to help resolve this properly, including geotechnical and tunnel endorsement and structural monitoring. WhatsApp +65 9342 7551. Last reviewed: November 2026.


Comments