ERSS Wall Types in Singapore: Sheet Piles Contiguous Bored Piles Secant Piles and Diaphragm Walls
The five embedded wall types used for earth retaining or stabilising structures (ERSS) in Singapore are soldier piles with lagging, steel sheet piles, contiguous bored piles, secant bored piles and diaphragm walls. They differ mainly in stiffness, water-tightness and whether they can become the permanent basement wall. Whatever the wall type, BCA's submission thresholds are the same: plan approval above 1.5 m depth, an Accredited Checker above 4 m, and a PE(Geo) and AC(Geo) above 6 m where the works are geotechnical building works. This article sits under our complete guide to geotechnical engineering in Singapore.
What counts as an ERSS wall in Singapore?
BCA defines an earth retaining structure as any structure, structural system or other means used to maintain the shape of an excavation during construction, earth filling or cutting. The wall is one part of the system. Advisory Note 1/09 treats the ERSS as including embedded walls, earth berms, struts, walers, connections, king posts and all components that are integral to stability.
Choosing a wall is therefore a decision about the whole system: the ground and groundwater, how close the neighbours are, how much movement they can tolerate and whether the wall will be left in as permanent works. For a general introduction see our overview of earth retaining structures.
Soldier piles and timber lagging
A soldier pile wall is a row of steel sections installed at intervals, with timber, steel or concrete lagging placed between them as excavation proceeds. It is the most economical embedded wall and the least water-tight, because the lagging is installed only after the soil face is exposed and it does not extend below the excavation level.
It suits shallower excavations in stiff soils that stand unsupported for a short time and where the groundwater table is low or drawdown is acceptable. It is a poor choice in soft marine clay or water-bearing sand next to buildings on shallow foundations. Soldier piles also appear inside soil-mix walls, where a steel section inserted in a grout mixed column carries the bending and shear. BCA's rule for that combination is covered in the ground improvement section below.
Steel sheet pile walls
A sheet pile wall is a continuous line of interlocking steel sections driven, vibrated or pressed into the ground. It is fast to install, reusable and reasonably water-tight when the interlocks are intact, which makes it common for basements of one or two levels, pile cap excavations, drains and utility trenches.
Its limits are flexibility and drivability. A sheet pile wall is far less stiff than a concrete wall, so it needs closer strut spacing to control deflection, and hard driving into dense or hard ground can split the interlocks (declutching). A gap in the wall within permeable or soft soil lets soil and water flow into the excavation and can end in a sinkhole at the surface.
What does BCA's December 2025 sheet pile circular require?
The joint BCA / ACES / IES / GeoSS circular APPBCA-2025-29 of 1 December 2025 sets a risk-based approach to keeping sheet pile interlocks intact, issued after ground loss incidents involving gaps in sheet pile walls, particularly in reclaimed sand. It is good practice guidance, except Section 4, which is a requirement for geotechnical building works with excavation deeper than 6 m. It applies to projects whose planning application or first structural plan submission is made on or after 1 June 2026.
Risk is classified by ground: Low where there is no Kallang Group or high-permeability soil, Medium where Kallang Group soils other than fluvial sand are present, and High where there is high-permeability soil such as reclaimed sand or fluvial sand. Key measures are:
Medium risk: for ERSS in Zone 1 (structures within one excavation depth of the wall), new or reused sheet piles with clutches in good condition, and grouting before excavation where improper interlocking is suspected.
High risk: in addition, press-in installation or an equivalent precise method, continuous installation records for Zone 1, and excavation that starts along the wall so the interlocks can be inspected first.
All categories: a crush piler or pre-augering in hard soil (SPT N above 30), press-in installation for walls within 1 m of a boundary wall or neighbouring property, and silent or low-impact methods in residential areas.
Section 4 (mandatory on the approved plans): the builder and site supervisors inspect the exposed sheet piles during excavation and report any gap to the supervising QP. Excavation stops in the affected area, and the contingency measures include backfilling to the previous excavation level for High risk, sealing the gap, and grouting behind the wall.
The circular also reminds designers that a cluster of inclinometer and piezometer or water standpipe should be installed at 30 to 40 m intervals along the wall, and that piping checks to Eurocode 7 clause 2.4.7 are needed for excavations in sand. Monitoring is covered in our article on instrumentation and monitoring for excavation works.
Contiguous bored pile and secant bored pile walls
A contiguous bored pile (CBP) wall is a row of reinforced bored piles cast close together with small gaps between them, and a secant pile wall is a row of piles that overlap so the wall is continuous. Both are stiffer than sheet piles and can be installed with little vibration close to existing buildings, including through hard ground and boulders that would stop a sheet pile.
The difference is water. A CBP wall is not water-tight because soil and water can pass through the gaps, so it is used where the retained ground is stiff and of low permeability or where the gaps are sealed by grouting behind the wall. In a secant wall, unreinforced primary piles are cast first and reinforced secondary piles are cut into them, which closes the gaps. Water-tightness then depends on the piles staying vertical enough to keep overlapping at depth, so the practical depth of a secant wall is limited by drilling tolerance.
Diaphragm walls
A diaphragm wall is a reinforced concrete wall cast in panels in a trench kept open by support fluid. It is the stiffest and most water-tight of the common wall types, can reach the greatest depths and usually serves as both the temporary excavation support and the permanent basement wall.
The joint BCA / LTA circular APPBCA-2026-22 of 9 October 2026 addresses the main quality problem, which is reinforcement congestion that prevents concrete flowing through the cage and leads to honeycombing and leaks. Its four key measures are:
Tremie concrete specified by slump flow of 400 mm to 550 mm, in place of a slump of 170 to 230 mm.
A design crack width of 0.30 mm, in line with SS EN 1992-1-1.
A minimum concrete cover of 75 mm, in place of the previous 90 mm.
A maximum of three layers of longitudinal reinforcement on each face at non-lapping areas (six at laps).
Trenching for a diaphragm wall also moves the ground. Advisory Note 1/09 requires adjacent ground to be monitored during trenching, with allowable limits set to protect neighbouring properties.
Can ground improvement be used as the retaining wall?
No. BCA's Geotechnical Building Works submission requirements (June 2026) state that ground improvement shall be limited to soil improvement work only and shall not be used as part of the retaining wall, especially as a cantilever retaining wall. Advisory Note 1/09 says the same of jet-grouted piles and deep soil mixing: they must not form part of the ERSS structural support or strutting system.
Where grout mixed piles are present within the retaining wall, BCA sets two minimum conditions:
All wall forces, including bending moments and shear forces, must be resisted by a separate structural system, such as steel soldier piles inserted in the grout mixed piles, analysed with the grout mixed piles ignored.
Separate structural lagging in concrete, timber or steel must be provided between the structural wall members.
BCA's August 2026 update to the ERSS submission requirements adds a check for "floating" ERSS, where ground improvement is used and the wall toe ends in soft soil: an additional accidental basal heave check ignoring the ground improvement, with a factor of safety of not less than 1.1. Ground improvement methods are described in our article on jet grouting, deep soil mixing and other techniques.
How are ERSS walls supported: struts, ground anchors and soil nails?
Embedded walls deeper than a few metres are propped by steel struts and walers, tied back with ground anchors, or in top-down construction propped by the permanent floor slabs. Strutting is the default in soft ground because it keeps all the support inside the site. Ground anchors leave the excavation clear but extend beneath neighbouring land, and Advisory Note 1/09 asks for site investigation along the line of the probable fixed anchor zone. Soil nails reinforce the soil mass itself and suit cut slopes and stiff residual soils, not soft clay.
Advisory Note 1/09 requires the design to be robust enough to survive one-strut failure, requires temporary ERSS to have a factor of safety not lower than permanent works, and requires the builder to obtain the QP's approval before excavating below every strut level.
Which wall type suits which ground, and what approvals apply?
In soft Kallang Formation clay beside buildings, a stiff wall such as a diaphragm or secant wall limits movement best, while sheet piles suit shallower or greenfield excavations. Advisory Note 1/09 caps wall deflection at 0.5% of excavation depth where structures lie within one excavation depth of the wall (Zone 1), 0.7% between one and two depths (Zone 2), and 0.7% or 1.0% beyond that depending on ground type.
BCA's ERSS submission requirements set the appointments by depth:
Up to 1.5 m deep (1 m if the retaining structure is not reinforced concrete or steel): no plan approval.
Above 1.5 m and up to 4 m: plans by a QP(ST).
Above 4 m and up to 6 m: QP(ST) and an Accredited Checker.
Above 6 m and classified as geotechnical building works, such as a basement excavation: QP(ST), QP(Geo), AC and AC(Geo).
The detail is in our article on ERSS submission thresholds and our guide to deep excavation and AC(Geo) requirements.
What goes wrong with ERSS walls
Most wall problems come from water finding a path through or under the wall, or from a wall that is too flexible for its surroundings. Common errors are:
Driving sheet piles hard into dense ground without pre-augering, which declutches the interlocks.
Leaving gaps where the wall meets existing utilities. BCA issued a separate circular on utility gaps within ERSS on 2 December 2024.
Relying on a jet grout or soil-mix block as if it were a structural wall.
Choosing a CBP wall in water-bearing soil without sealing the gaps.
Too little toe embedment for basal heave, hydraulic uplift or piping.
Congested diaphragm wall cages that leak after excavation.
FAQ
Which ERSS wall type is the most water-tight?
A properly constructed diaphragm wall. BCA describes diaphragm walls as providing superior water-tightness when executed to proper standards. Secant pile walls and intact sheet pile walls come next, and contiguous bored pile and soldier pile walls are not water-tight.
What is the difference between contiguous and secant piles?
Contiguous piles are cast with small gaps between them. Secant piles overlap, so the wall is continuous and can cut off groundwater.
Does a sheet pile wall need a PE(Geo)?
Only when the excavation is more than 6 m deep and classed as geotechnical building works. Between 1.5 m and 4 m a QP(ST) alone submits the plans, and between 4 m and 6 m an Accredited Checker is added.
Can a soil-mix or jet grout wall retain an excavation by itself?
No. BCA requires all wall forces to be carried by a separate structural system, with lagging between the structural members.
When does the sheet pile integrity circular apply?
To geotechnical building works projects, except those that submitted their planning application to URA before 1 June 2026 and then received provisional permission or Design Gateway clearance. Where no planning permission is needed, it applies if the first structural plan submission is on or after 1 June 2026.
Is a diaphragm wall always permanent?
Not always, but it usually is. Where the temporary wall also serves as the permanent basement wall, BCA requires the temporary and permanent works to be submitted together as geotechnical building works.
Sources
CVC Engineers advocates education and public awareness, and has a dedicated team to help resolve this properly, including ERSS submissions. WhatsApp +65 9342 7551. Last reviewed: November 2026.


Comments