The Observational Method in Singapore Excavations: How the BCA Framework Works
The observational method is a way of designing an excavation in which the engineer prepares two designs in advance, one cautious and one based on the most probable ground behaviour, and uses monitoring during construction to decide which one to build. In Singapore it is governed by BCA circular APPBCA-2019-12, the Framework on Observational Method for the Design and Construction of ERSS Work, and Ground Water Control for Deep Excavation, dated 2 September 2019. Under the framework the method may be used only for multi-propped earth retaining systems, only after pre-consultation with BCA, and only with every trigger level and contingency fixed on the approved plans before work starts. This article is part of our complete guide to geotechnical engineering in Singapore.
What is the observational method?
The observational method is a planned process of design, monitoring and pre-agreed modification, in which the design is adjusted during construction according to how the ground actually behaves. It was set out by Ralph Peck in his 1969 Rankine Lecture and is recognised in Eurocode 7 as an approach for situations where geotechnical behaviour is difficult to predict.
Peck's essential conditions still define the method. The designer must establish the most probable conditions and the most unfavourable conceivable ones, choose what will be observed, calculate in advance the values expected under each, and prepare a course of action for every foreseeable departure from the prediction. It is not the same as reacting to monitoring results after something has gone wrong. If the modification has not been designed beforehand, it is not the observational method.
The benefit is economy without loss of safety. Ordinary design uses cautious parameters throughout, so retaining systems often perform better than predicted. The observational method lets a project take advantage of that better performance in a controlled way.
What does BCA's framework APPBCA-2019-12 cover?
The circular has two parts: Annex A for the design and construction of ERSS work, and Annex B for groundwater control systems in deep excavation. It was developed by a BCA-Industry Joint Working Committee with input from IES, ACES and GeoSS, and is for compliance by Qualified Persons (QPs), Accredited Checkers (ACs), site supervisors, builders and developers submitting proposals that adopt the method.
BCA's stated purpose is to promote work efficiency and construction productivity without compromising safety. The circular advises developers and builders to engage experienced QPs with good track records and to allow for the additional design work and closer monitoring that the method demands.
When may the observational method be used?
It may be used only where six criteria in Annex A1 are met and BCA has confirmed at pre-consultation that the proposal is applicable.
Track record: the QPs have at least 2 projects of similar scale in similar ground conditions with well documented design and monitoring reports, and no stop work order related to inadequate design within the past 3 years.
Applicability: the ERSS scheme is multi-propped, and the QPs have pre-consulted BCA.
Dual design: the design uses both characteristic and most probable parameters.
Adequate ground investigation to support both sets of parameters.
Review levels set according to the framework.
Sufficient instrumentation.
For ground investigation, the framework requires parameters derived by statistical methods from a comprehensive investigation, with a minimum of 10 samples for strength and a minimum of 10 pressuremeter tests for stiffness, and soil sampling within each layer. Data from an adjacent site may be used only if some tests are carried out on the site itself to verify it. Investigation requirements generally are covered in our guide to soil investigation in Singapore.
When is the observational method not appropriate?
The framework excludes four categories of work:
Floating ERSS, where the wall toe is not embedded into stiff soil with an SPT N value of more than 15, that falls within Zone 1 or Zone 2 as defined in Advisory Note 1/09.
Slopes, including earth slopes, open-cut slopes and nailed slopes.
Cantilever or single-strut ERSS.
Mined excavation.
The reasoning follows from the method itself. It depends on having time to observe a trend and act on it, and on having a support that can still be installed. Systems that can fail suddenly, or that have no second line of support to fall back on, do not give that time. Wall and support systems are compared in our article on ERSS wall types in Singapore.
What must be predefined in the design?
Two complete scenarios must be designed and shown on the approved plans: the Characteristic Scenario (CS) and the Probable Scenario (PS).
The CS uses characteristic parameters, the cautious estimates normally adopted under Eurocode 7. BCA notes that the CS should correspond to the usual design without the observational method.
The PS uses most probable parameters, which may be taken as the average of the available values.
Stability checks, such as wall toe embedment and global stability, are always based on characteristic parameters.
The wall and supports are designed for the most onerous of the two analyses, that is, the envelope of both runs.
Construction starts on the CS.
An onerous groundwater condition is adopted in both.
The two scenarios must be compatible, so that a switch back from PS to CS can be made at any time without structural issues or obstructions.
The only optimisation the framework allows during construction is the reduction of struts or props, and only when the actual performance at the Decision Stage and afterwards is within the design limits of the PS. How Eurocode 7 defines characteristic values is explained in our article on Eurocode 7 in Singapore.
What are the trigger levels?
The framework adds two observational method levels on top of the usual alert and work suspension levels, and all of them must be specified on the approved plans for each critical construction stage. They cover wall deflection and support forces, among other measurements.
OM Implementation Level (OMIL): a percentage of the OM Design Level. Performance within it means the PS is well on route, and the QP may proceed with the next stage on the PS.
OM Design Level (OMDL): the value predicted by the PS. Between OMIL and OMDL is the Decision Zone, where the QP deliberates whether to adopt CS or PS.
Predetermined Level (PDL): the value predicted by the CS. Beyond OMDL but within PDL, the method cannot be realised. If the works are on the PS, the QP must immediately instruct erection of the supports and reversion to the CS.
Beyond PDL but within the Work Suspension Level: the QP reviews the design, assesses the need for strengthening, makes an amendment submission before further excavation and reports to BCA by email.
Alert Level: the QP closely monitors the ERSS.
Work Suspension Level: the QP immediately suspends all excavation, reports to BCA and carries out strengthening works.
BCA's worked example makes this concrete. For a strut that might be omitted at excavation stage 5, a wall deflection below 16 mm allows the strut to be omitted, 16 to 20 mm calls for deliberation, 20 to 35 mm means the strut cannot be omitted, and 35 to 51 mm requires design review and an amendment submission. These figures are illustrative for that example only.
How does this relate to the levels in Advisory Note 1/09?
The alert and work suspension levels are the ordinary ones from BCA Advisory Note 1/09, which apply to every ERSS whether or not the observational method is used. The framework describes them as standard practice independent of the method.
Under Advisory Note 1/09, the work suspension level is the allowable maximum wall deflection: 0.5% of the excavation depth H where structures lie within a distance H of the excavation (Zone 1), 0.7%H where they lie between H and 2H (Zone 2), and 0.7%H or 1.0%H beyond 2H depending on ground type. The alert level is 70% of that value, and a check level at 50% applies where structures are in Zones 2 and 3. The QP must inform BCA immediately when the alert or work suspension level is exceeded. The observational method levels sit below these and never replace them.
What contingency measures and instrumentation are required?
The materials for any support omitted under the PS must be kept on site or in a store, ready to be deployed within a day, from the Decision Stage until the base slab is cast or any later critical stage. This must be stated on the approved plans.
Instrumentation requirements in Annex A6 are:
Instrumented arrays at a maximum interval of 30 m.
Each array to include an inclinometer and a support strain gauge or load cell.
Inclinometers read daily after the Decision Stage of adopting the PS, until the base slab is cast or any later critical stage.
Strain gauges or load cells read at least daily, with the QP to decide whether real-time monitoring with SMS alerts is needed.
Before deciding to adopt the PS, the QP must also check that building instruments are within the limits assessed for that stage. Instrument types and reading practice are described in our article on instrumentation and monitoring for excavation works.
Who does what, and what goes to BCA?
Each decision to proceed on the Probable Scenario is certified by the builder, the supervising QPs and the design QPs on form Exc_OM_AnnexC-1, which is submitted to BCA through CORENET e-correspondence before the works proceed.
Builder: the technical controller confirms that the ERSS has been built according to the approved plans and seeks the QPs' approval, and keeps the support materials available.
Supervising QP and supervising QP(Geo): inspect and record the status, reporting any deviation from the approved plans.
Design QP and design QP(Geo): assess the as-installed structural elements, the monitoring results and the actual ground conditions, and certify that the next stage can proceed on the PS.
BCA: confirms applicability at pre-consultation, approves plans showing both scenarios and all levels, receives the form at each Decision Stage, and is notified by email if the PDL is breached.
The form is used in addition to the usual site inspection and approval record for geotechnical building works. The wider supervision regime is described in our guide to deep excavation and AC(Geo) requirements.
How does the method apply to groundwater control?
Annex B lets QPs optimise the base slab of a deep excavation in the temporary stage where active or passive groundwater pressure relief is assumed, provided an effective water control system is implemented. The QP must demonstrate at least one case of successful groundwater control for deep excavation, and neither the builder nor the QP may have had a stop work order related to groundwater drawdown in the past 3 years.
The approved plans must specify water cut-off measures supported by seepage analysis and field permeability tests, recharge wells pre-installed where buildings lie within the influence zone, piezometers at the border of the influence zone, settlement markers on buildings and a contingency plan. The contingency examples listed include flooding the shaft, additional grouting and recharge wells, sealing relief wells and strengthening the base slab. See our article on groundwater control and dewatering.
What goes wrong with the observational method?
The method fails when it is used as a label for cutting supports without the discipline the framework requires.
No designed fallback. If the CS has not been fully designed and detailed, there is nothing to revert to.
Incompatible scenarios, where a strut omitted under the PS can no longer be installed because of obstructions.
Support materials not on site, so reversion takes longer than the ground allows.
Sparse or late monitoring, so that a trend is missed between readings.
Too little ground data to justify "most probable" parameters.
Treating the observational method levels as a substitute for the alert and work suspension levels.
FAQ
Is the observational method allowed in Singapore?
Yes, for ERSS work and groundwater control in deep excavation, under BCA circular APPBCA-2019-12 dated 2 September 2019. Pre-consultation with BCA is required.
Can the observational method be used for slopes or cantilever walls?
No. The BCA framework excludes slopes, cantilever and single-strut ERSS, mined excavation, and floating ERSS within Zone 1 or Zone 2 as defined in Advisory Note 1/09.
What can be saved by using it?
Under the framework, the optimisation during construction applies to the reduction of struts or props. The wall itself is designed for the envelope of both scenarios.
What is the difference between the Characteristic Scenario and the Probable Scenario?
The Characteristic Scenario uses cautious characteristic soil parameters and matches the usual design. The Probable Scenario uses most probable, typically average, parameters and represents the likely behaviour during construction.
How often must instruments be read?
Inclinometers daily and strut strain gauges or load cells at least daily, from the Decision Stage until the base slab is cast or any later critical stage, with arrays at a maximum spacing of 30 m.
What happens if the wall moves more than the Probable Scenario predicted?
The QP must immediately instruct the builder to erect the supports and revert to the Characteristic Scenario. The materials must be on site or in a store and deployable within a day.
Does the observational method change the work suspension level?
No. The alert and work suspension levels in Advisory Note 1/09 continue to apply independently.
Sources
CVC Engineers advocates education and public awareness, and has a dedicated team to help resolve this properly, including PE geotechnical endorsement and structural monitoring. WhatsApp +65 9342 7551. Last reviewed: November 2026.


Comments