Hacking vs Demolition in Singapore: Which Works Need BCA Approval and a PE
Updated: Nov 12
"Hacking" is a trade word, not a legal one. Singapore's Building Control Regulations 2003 do not ask whether a wall is being hacked or demolished; they ask whether the element is structural. Demolishing or opening up a non-load bearing wall is insignificant building works that needs no BCA plan approval or permit, while removing or altering any structural element needs plans approved by BCA, a permit, and supervision by a Qualified Person (QP).
What is the difference between hacking and demolition?
There is no legal difference in the name; the difference lies in what is being removed. In practice the terms are used like this:
Hacking of finishes: removing tiles, screed, plaster or built-in fittings without touching the wall or slab behind.
Hacking a non-load bearing wall: removing or forming an opening in a partition wall that carries no load from the building.
Hacking that affects structural elements: cutting into or removing beams, columns, load-bearing or shear walls, or floor slabs, for example to form a staircase void or widen an opening.
Partial demolition: taking down part of a building, such as a rear extension, a floor or a roof, while the rest stays standing.
Total demolition: taking down the whole building, usually ahead of redevelopment.
Which hacking works need no BCA approval?
Works listed in the First Schedule of the Building Control Regulations 2003 need no BCA plan approval or permit. The items relevant to hacking are:
Item (o): creating an opening in a non-load bearing wall, or sealing up a wall opening.
Item (p): demolition, restoration or reinstatement of any non-load bearing wall.
Item (w): removal of any loft of timber or steel construction.
Paragraph 4A: demolition of a suspended lightweight false ceiling.
"No BCA approval" does not mean "no approval". HDB, a management corporation (MCST) or a landlord such as JTC can still require its own consent, and someone still has to establish that the wall really is non-load bearing. The full list is in our guide to insignificant building works.
When does hacking need BCA approval and a Professional Engineer?
Hacking needs BCA approval as soon as a structural element is involved. BCA's 2014 advisory on control of renovation works states that all demolition works involving structural elements require plans approved by the Commissioner of Building Control and a permit to commence, and must be supervised by a Qualified Person, under sections 5, 6 and 8 of the Building Control Act. The advisory names beams, columns and shear walls as key structural elements.
Only a QP who is a Professional Engineer (PE) in the civil or structural discipline can apply for structural plan approval. Two concessions in the Fourth Schedule keep smaller jobs simpler: demolition of any building or structure, item (l), and alterations that do not materially affect key structural elements, paragraph 2, do not require an Accredited Checker's certificate. They still need the QP's submission and the permit. Carrying out building works without approved plans or a permit carries a fine of up to $200,000, up to 2 years' imprisonment, or both. See PE endorsement versus QP submission for the difference between the two routes.
Which approvals apply to HDB flats, condos, landed homes and commercial or industrial units?
The BCA rule is the same everywhere, but the landlord or strata layer differs by property type.
HDB flats: HDB sets its own guidelines for building works, including demolition of walls. A PE in the civil or structural discipline must supervise demolition of non-structural reinforced concrete elements, and block or brick walls may be demolished only up to the underside of the reinforced concrete beam or slab, working from the top down.
Condominiums and other strata units: the MCST approves renovation in each lot. BCA's 2014 advisory asks MCSTs to require, for any demolition other than floor tiles, renovation plans endorsed by a PE in the civil or structural discipline certifying that no structural works are involved, drawn against the original approved plans, with the work done by contractors whose workers are trained and certified by the BCA Academy.
Landed homes: there is no MCST, so the owner deals with BCA directly. Removing a non-load bearing wall is exempt; cutting slabs, removing columns or taking down part of the house is not. Houses not exceeding 3 storeys need no Accredited Checker. A full knock-down goes to BCA and URA as a demolition submission.
Commercial and industrial units: BCA rules apply, plus the landlord's. A JTC fitting-out guide for one of its multi-tenanted buildings requires JTC's endorsement for alteration works including demolition and hacking into walls, floors, ceilings and pillars, and JTC's written consent before the floor structure is drilled or hacked. See our JTC factory renovation guide.
Our article on hacking walls in HDB, condo and landed homes goes through the residential cases in more depth.
Who approves what: BCA, HDB, MCST, JTC and URA?
Each body controls a different aspect of the same hacking job.
BCA: plan approval, permit and QP supervision for any work involving structural elements.
HDB: works inside HDB flats, under its renovation guidelines.
MCST: renovation inside strata lots and common property. Under section 37(4) of the Building Maintenance and Strata Management Act, the management corporation can impose conditions to protect the building's key structural elements before approving renovation.
JTC and other landlords: consent under the lease or tenancy.
URA: demolition ahead of redevelopment, and any works to conserved buildings. In July 2025 URA charged an owner and an individual over unauthorised works, including demolition of a rear facade and an original timber staircase, at a conserved shophouse; the Planning Act offence carries a fine of up to $500,000, up to 12 months' imprisonment, or both.
MOM and NEA: worker safety, asbestos surveys for buildings built before 1 January 1991, and construction noise.
How do you tell whether a wall is structural?
The approved structural plans decide it, checked against what is actually on site. The PE certification annexed to BCA's 2014 advisory requires the engineer to have personally checked the approved structural plan and inspected the structural condition of the unit before certifying that no structural element will be altered or demolished. The advisory also tells MCSTs to keep a full set of approved structural plans for owners to use; our guide explains how to buy approved structural plans from BCA. Wall thickness, the sound of a knock, or a contractor's memory of a similar unit are not evidence.
What goes wrong when hacking is treated as minor work?
The usual failure is a structural element being cut by someone who believed it was a partition. BCA issued its 2014 advisory after cases of unauthorised demolition of structural elements during renovation in strata-titled buildings, some of which led to Dangerous Building Orders being served on the management corporation. The same advisory says that whenever structural reinforcement bars are exposed, work must stop, a PE must be called in to assess and recommend remedial measures, and BCA should be notified.
Non-structural walls also kill when hacked badly. The WSH Council reports that on 1 November 2024 a worker hacking a concrete wall at a private residence under renovation died when the wall collapsed on him; he was working alone. Its Technical Advisory for Demolition records a partition wall, hacked from the bottom up, collapsing into a public area, killing one person and injuring four. The Council recommends a progressive top-down approach and hacking large wall segments into smaller sections. Where structural work has already been done without approval, see regularisation of unauthorised works.
FAQ
Do I need a PE to hack a wall in my condo?
For a non-load bearing wall, BCA does not require plan approval, but BCA has advised MCSTs to require renovation plans endorsed by a PE certifying that no structural works are involved. For a structural wall, a QP's submission to BCA and a permit are required.
Can I hack a wall in my HDB flat?
Only in line with HDB's guidelines. Block or brick walls may be demolished only up to the underside of the reinforced concrete beam or slab, from the top down, and a PE must supervise demolition of non-structural reinforced concrete elements.
Is hacking floor tiles regulated?
BCA's 2014 advisory excludes hacking of floor tiles from its PE certification and trained-worker recommendations. Your MCST or HDB may still set working hours and other conditions.
Does making a door opening in a wall need BCA approval?
Not if the wall is non-load bearing: that is item (o) of the First Schedule. An opening in a load-bearing or shear wall is structural work and needs approval.
What should a contractor do if rebar appears during hacking?
Stop work. BCA's advisory says a PE shall be called in to assess and recommend remedial measures, and BCA should be notified.
Sources
CVC Engineers advocates education and public awareness, and has a dedicated team to help resolve this properly, from PE endorsement of renovation plans to additions and alterations submissions. To check whether your hacking works need approval, WhatsApp or call +65 9342 7551. Last reviewed: November 2026.


Comments