top of page
CVC Engineers Pte Ltd

Design and Build vs Traditional Contracts in Singapore: How Each Model Works

Nov 12
8 min read

In the traditional model, also called design-bid-build, the owner appoints consultants, completes the design, tenders it, and a builder constructs what has been drawn. In design and build (D&B), one contractor takes responsibility for both the design and the construction. The Building and Construction Authority (BCA) describes D&B as a procurement method where the functions of design and construction are placed entirely with the builder. The choice changes who carries design risk and who engages the consultants, but it does not change the Building Control Act: every project still needs a developer, Qualified Persons (QPs), a licensed builder and, for major building works, an Accredited Checker.

What is the traditional design-bid-build model?

In design-bid-build the owner engages the architect and engineers directly, the design is completed before tender, and builders price a defined set of drawings and specifications. Three features follow from that sequence:

  • The consultants owe their contractual duties to the owner, so the owner controls the design from first sketch to tender.

  • The builder is responsible for workmanship and for building to the drawings, while responsibility for the adequacy of the design sits with the owner's consultants.

  • Tenders are comparable because every builder prices the same documents.

The cost of this clarity is time and interface risk. Design and construction run one after the other, and when a drawing is late, unclear or changed, the builder usually has a claim for a variation or for more time.

What is design and build?

In design and build the owner states its requirements and a single contractor designs and constructs the works for an agreed price. BCA's guide for public sector projects (updated January 2020) sets out the procedure: the employer develops a design brief and tender documents, each pre-qualified builder engages its own consultants to develop a design proposal and submits a bid, and the successful builder develops and constructs the project according to the accepted proposal. The guide adds that the duties and responsibilities of the Qualified Persons are undertaken by the consultancy team under the awarded builder.

The attraction is a single point of responsibility. If a defect appears, the owner does not have to work out whether it is a design fault or a workmanship fault before deciding whom to pursue. Design and construction can also overlap, and the builder's knowledge of methods and materials shapes the design from the start. The trade-off is that the owner gives up day-to-day control of the design once the contract is signed.

What variants sit between the two models?

BCA identifies three early contractor involvement models for public sector projects, distinguished by the stage at which the builder joins. From its January 2020 guide:

  1. Design and Build (D&B): the builder develops the full architectural, civil and structural, and mechanical and electrical design from a design brief.

  2. Design Development and Build (DDB): the employer's consultants prepare the architectural concept design, and the builder develops the detailed design from it. The employer may retain its consultants in the project management team, novate their services to the awarded builder, or let builders engage their own consultants.

  3. Design Bid Build with Early Contractor Involvement (DBB-ECI): the employer keeps control of the full design, and pre-qualified builders work with the consultants during tender to offer alternative design solutions that save time or cost. An alternative that costs more than the base tender is not accepted.

In all three models the guide limits the tender stage to at most four pre-qualified builders and evaluates bids under the Price Quality Method. Outside the public sector the same ideas appear under other names: develop-and-construct, where the contractor completes a design the owner has started; novation, where the owner's consultants are transferred to the contractor after award; and design-build-operate, where the contractor also runs the completed facility for a period. Collaborative contracting is a separate layer that can sit on either model. It is covered in our article on construction procurement trends in Singapore.

How do the two models compare?

The two models allocate the same risks differently. These are general contract principles, and the wording of the actual contract always governs.

  • Responsibility: traditional contracts split design (consultants) from construction (builder). D&B places both with the contractor.

  • Design risk: under a traditional contract, an error in the drawings is generally the owner's risk as against the builder. Under D&B, the contractor carries it, and D&B forms often set a fitness for purpose standard that is more onerous than a consultant's duty of reasonable skill and care. In March 2025 BCA announced that the Government would review the fit for purpose clauses in the public sector D&B form to balance risk between the parties.

  • Cost certainty: a D&B lump sum is fixed earlier, on less design information, so it is only as firm as the owner's requirements. A traditional tender is priced later but against a complete design.

  • Time: D&B allows design and construction to overlap. The traditional sequence is longer but each stage is settled before the next begins.

  • Design control: the traditional owner approves every detail. The D&B owner controls the brief and then reviews, rather than directs, the design.

  • Variations: owner changes after award are costly in both models, but in D&B they also disturb a design that the contractor has priced as a whole.

  • Quality: in D&B the contractor chooses how to meet the brief, so anything the owner cares about has to be written into the requirements. In a traditional contract it is drawn and specified.

  • Tendering cost: D&B bidders must design before they can price, which is why BCA's guide restricts the number of bidders.

Which model suits which type of project?

No model is right for every project, and the deciding factor is usually how much of the design the owner needs to control.

  • Landed house: owners who want a particular architectural result usually appoint their own architect and engineer and tender the completed design. D&B suits an owner who wants one contract and one price and is prepared to fix the requirements early.

  • Factory or warehouse: where the brief is functional, such as floor loading, clear height, column grid and crane capacity, D&B works well because the performance can be stated and tested. Process-critical items such as machine foundations still need to be specified by the owner.

  • Additions and alterations: existing buildings hide unknowns. A traditional route, or a D&B contract let only after the existing structure has been investigated, limits arguments about who bears the cost of what is found. See our guide to A&A submissions.

  • Public sector: agencies use both models. BCA publishes the Public Sector Standard Conditions of Contract in a Construction Works version and a Design and Build version, and its guide encourages early contractor involvement for projects of larger value or greater complexity.

The standard forms that go with each model are compared in our article on standard construction contracts in Singapore.

How does each model affect authority submissions and QP roles?

The statutory roles are identical under both models; only the party who engages the QPs changes. Section 8 of the Building Control Act 1989 requires the developer to appoint an appropriate QP to prepare the plans and an appropriate QP to supervise the works, in each case if no such person is appointed by the builder. Section 11 requires the builder to appoint those QPs where the developer has not. That is the statutory basis for D&B: the contractor may engage the design and supervision QPs.

Three points do not move with the contract:

  • The permit to carry out structural works is applied for jointly by the developer, the QP and the builder, as BCA's permit page states.

  • The Accredited Checker for major building works is appointed by the developer under section 8, not by the builder.

  • A QP may not supervise the structural elements of major building works if the QP is a partner, officer or employee of the developer, the builder or their associates (section 9(7)). The same bar applies to site supervisors (section 10(4)).

The submission sequence is also unchanged: planning permission first, technical agency clearances, then building plan and structural plan approval, the permit, and finally TOP and CSC. See QP submission step by step and the order of authority submissions. On CORENET X, which is mandatory for new projects of 30,000 sqm gross floor area and above since 1 October 2025 and 5,000 sqm and above from 1 October 2026, the disciplines submit a coordinated model at each gateway, which rewards a team that is integrated early. Our CORENET X guide explains the gateways. The roles are examined in detail in Design and Build in Singapore: Roles of the QP Builder and Developer.

Which authority or document governs what?

  • Building Control Act 1989: who must be appointed, their duties and independence, and the offences. It applies whatever the contract says.

  • BCA: plan approval, permits, the public sector contract forms and the procurement frameworks for government projects.

  • The contract: price, time, design responsibility, variations, payment and defects. The parties choose it.

  • Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2004: a statutory right to progress payments and adjudication that overlays the contract.

  • Professional Engineers Board and Board of Architects: registration of the engineers and architects who act as QPs.

What goes wrong

  • The brief is thin. In D&B the owner's requirements are the benchmark for everything, and what is not written is priced out.

  • The owner assumes D&B transfers its statutory duties. It does not: the owner is still the developer under the Act.

  • The supervising QP for major building works turns out to be on the builder's payroll, which section 9(7) prohibits.

  • The Accredited Checker is treated as part of the contractor's package. The Act requires the developer to appoint the checker, and the checker must have no professional or financial interest in the works. See when your project needs an Accredited Checker.

  • Owner changes are instructed informally, and the time and cost effects surface only at the final account.

  • In a traditional contract, late or incomplete drawings become the builder's best claim.

FAQ

Is design and build cheaper than the traditional route?

Not necessarily. D&B can shorten the programme and gives a price earlier, but the contractor prices the design risk it carries. A complete design tendered competitively can be equally economical.

Who is the Qualified Person in a design and build project?

A registered architect or professional engineer, as in any project. The difference is that the QP may be appointed by the builder instead of the developer, which sections 8 and 11 of the Building Control Act permit.

Can the D&B contractor's own engineer supervise the works?

Not the structural elements of major building works. Section 9(7) bars a supervising QP who is a partner, officer or employee of the developer or builder, or of their associates.

Does the owner still need an independent engineer in D&B?

There is no legal requirement beyond the statutory appointments, but many owners retain an engineer to write the requirements, review the contractor's design and check the works. The developer must in any case appoint the Accredited Checker for major building works.

Which model does the public sector use?

Both. BCA publishes standard conditions for construction works and for design and build, and identifies D&B, DDB and DBB-ECI as early contractor involvement models for public projects.

Can consultants be transferred to the contractor after tender?

Yes. BCA's guide lists novation of the employer's consultants to the awarded builder as one option under the DDB model.

Sources

CVC Engineers advocates education and public awareness, and has a dedicated team to help resolve this properly, on either procurement route. See our BCA submission services and professional engineer consultation pages, or WhatsApp +65 9342 7551. Last reviewed: November 2026.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


© 2024 CVC Engineers. All rights reserved.

bottom of page